Strange Things about Robin Hood
Posted 16 March 2008 in Television by Catriona
(Nick suggested that I call this post “This, I Do Not Like,” but . . . no.)
I really enjoy Robin Hood, despite the fact that it’s very silly in parts. I’m fairly certain that one of the main reasons I like it is that Robin is one of the few genuinely English legends out there, along with King Arthur and Jack the Giant Killer.
I discussed it with my sister at one point, and she was uncertain about the idea, pointing out that it doesn’t even employ any of the main tropes, including the archery contest. My father, on the other hand, never misses an episode.
But there are stranger things about the show than the omission of the archery contest.
I feel a numerical list is warranted.
1. The fact that I’m blogging about it instead of just watching it.
2. Nick suggested that the hats in tonight’s episode probably weren’t period-appropriate. I don’t know about that, but I’m pretty sure that belted trenchcoats weren’t popular in the reign of Richard the Lionheart.
3. Ditto Guy of Gisbourne’s black-leather duster. But, really, who cares? It’s Guy of Gisbourne (or, as a friend calls him, “Lord, Have Mercy!”)
4. Marian’s over-the-dress corsets also cause me some concern. But Nick says I’m to leave those out of it.
5. In the middle of blogging I just came across the lines
“I’m not a Judas!”
“And I’m not Jesus.”
Well, no.
6. I’m fairly certain that Robin Hood didn’t earn his name because of his predilection for khaki-coloured hoodies.
7. Where is Friar Tuck? Nick swears he saw him in an early episode, but there’s been no real sign of it.
8. Shouldn’t Alan-a-Dale be a minstrel? Sure, any regular player of RPGs, especially table-top RPGs, knows that bards/minstrels are the most irritating of all character classes (although Nick suggests that if I’d ever played Dragonlance I would have found Kenders fairly annoying), but still, Alan is supposed to be a minstrel.
9. Will Scarlet’s memorial to his father, which was on par—despite the brilliance of Harry Lloyd’s performances—with the end of Van Helsing.
10. That Nick could tell that Sir Edward was going to die from his first appearance in the episode.
11. That Robin owes less to his literary ancestors and more to Marvel superheroes in his ability to completely and utterly defy the laws of physics.
12. Poor Much the Miller’s Son being relegated to the position of comic relief. Not appropriate for a Troughton.
13. They’ve just advertised next week’s episode as including a “Terminator.” I realise that that’s a metaphor, but, honestly, let’s not push the modern references too far, okay?
14. On that note, we’ve not only had an episode called “I Shot The Sheriff,” but we’re apparently about to have one called “Get Carter.” If that includes Michael Caine, I’ll be reasonably happy. If it stars Sylvester Stallone, I’m out of here.
15. The impunity with which they can wander around Nottingham with only the barest of disguises.
16. The casino episode. I know it co-starred Dexter Fletcher, and I realise that Wikipedia suggests that craps may date back to the Crusades, but really—did you not think we would notice that the mise en scene was distinctly Vegas?
Did I miss anything?
